On the surface, there’s no difference in number of racing fatalities

Written by VIVIAN GRANT

Thoroughbred racing gathered together today to talk about why horses are breaking down and dying on racetracks. The object of their attention is once again — racing surfaces — just as it always seems to be when racehorse safety comes up.

The excellent Tom LaMarra sums up the day in the Blood Horse.

An initial analysis of equine injury data released earlier this year shows no statistically significant difference in the risk of fatalities in Thoroughbreds on different racing surfaces, officials said June 28 during the third Welfare and Safety of the Racehorse Summit.

It appears to me (and a handful of others in horse racing with their thinking caps on) there is good reason for this, and we do not need a clever Scotsman to tell us. Perhaps it is not the surfaces the horses are running on. Why not take a critical look at breeding, drugging and training practices, including how often horses are run and at what age.

But no, officials will press on with this for awhile longer, it seems.

The analysis of information contained in the Equine Injury Database looked at factors that could be associated with fatal breakdowns. The results are strictly preliminary; in fact, officials said it could take a few more years of data to even consider a more detailed study.

“This will take time,” said Dr. Tim Parkin of the University of Glasgow in Scotland. “There are no quick answers. We need to consider (multi-factor models), but we probably need at least three years of full data.”

Non-fatal injuries will probably be addressed in the future, he added.

There were a few interesting statistics gathered from the database analysis.

The analysis also showed female horses had a lower fatality rate than intact male horses; that females weren’t at increased risk when they compete against males; that 2-year-olds were less likely to break down than older horses; that there was no statistically significant difference in fatal injuries with various surface conditions, such as fast or muddy; and that distance and weight had little variance as well.

In general, 2-year-olds were 30%-35% less likely to suffer a fatal injury than older horses. Females were 50% as likely as intact males to suffer a fatal injury.

2-year-olds are less likely to break down than older horses? What older horses? A high proportion of racehorses are too broken down to run or dead by the time they are 3 or 4; a little older if they are lucky enough to have a conscientious owner, trainer and veterinarian.

Next, officials are going to see if they can blame the weather, groundskeepers, the jockeys, or even the horses themselves, for their breaking down and dying.

Parkin noted there are many more factors that could be considered—season, track maintenance, quality of horses, and experience of jockeys, to name only a few—when future data is analyzed.

Parkin concludes with this.

That type of multi-factor analysis could lead to more definitive results; then again, it’s possible the initial numbers won’t change that much.

The initial numbers won’t change that much. Uh, huh.

Read Mr. LaMarra’s full article >>

Related Reading:

Racing executives remain complacent and clueless while horses suffer and die, Vivian Grant, Tuesday’s Horse (Jun. 28, 2010)

3 thoughts on “On the surface, there’s no difference in number of racing fatalities”

  1. Thank You !!!! I have been following the Race Horse memorial wall for years, Its a very sad place, but at least we can find out how many fallen racehorses there are cause its document there.!!! We have that as a place to find numbers and names and instances……those figures and names may be needed very soon….

    Like

  2. Its about time this issue is addressed, Race Horses are breaking way toooooo much, problem is these talks take for ever, and never seem to be constructive enough to take care of the problem………………………If you go to a site called racehorse memorial wall you can see just how many break down……………………….

    Like

    1. The racing industry is hooked on breeding for quantity not quality because they can get rid of the excess in slaughterhouses. It is the breeding element in horse racing that will be its ultimate downfall. Many advocates say hurrah about that.

      The fallen racehorse memorial you refer to is located at http://scrollsequus.blogspot.com/. This is a mighty awareness raising tool, and an unsung hero of these horses. You can also follow them on Twitter at http://twitter.com/equuseditorial.

      Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s