Big Licker served 55 felony counts for filthy, emaciated Tennessee Walking Horses

Cross-posted from The Chattanoogan »

ROY EXUM. Source image.
ROY EXUM. Source image.

In what was described as “a scene from some sick horror movie,” Giles County sheriff’s deputies and animal welfare officers raided the farm of known “Big Licker” Jeffery Alan Mitchell near Pulaski, Tn., last week and confiscated 55 Tennessee Walking Horses, all horribly malnourished and some that were so emaciated they could no longer walk.

By Sunday, the horses were receiving medical attention and care at several rescue facilities while Mitchell, who has quite a record of abusing horses in the past, was free on a $55,000 bond after being served with 55 counts of felony horse abuse.

According to Giles County Chief Deputy Tommy Chapman, “The animals were not in good physical health.

    “Two weanlings were found in a horse trailer without food or water and Jamie Clifton, one of the rescuers, said both young horses were still in critical condition yesterday. He said, “On what we call a Body Condition Scale, with ‘1’ being skin-and-bones and ‘9’ being obese, the entire herd was ‘2’ or less. These animals are in real bad shape.

    “The veterinarians have already euthanized one horse and we have immediate concerns over a couple of others, plus the weanlings,” said Clifton, who is the executive director of Volunteer Equine Advocates in Gallatin.

    “We’ve taken the animals to different secure locations but it is going to be a long time before they are ‘4’ to ‘5’ on the Body Condition Scale, which is what would be normal for a Tennessee Walker.”

Many of the confiscated horses will have to be shaved, the filth in the animals’ hair now like concrete, and most were standing in a filthy mix of excrement, mud, foul hay, and dirt. There was no food anywhere and it was estimated it had been days, or weeks, since the animals had eaten. “It’s unspeakable what these horses have endured,” said Clifton. “The neglect has really taken a toll on them and we still have a couple that are too sick to transport very far.”

Mitchell, allegedly fired as a pharmacist in Pulaski following his arrest, is known for his connection with the “Big Lick” arm of the Tennessee Walking Horse industry where soring methods are used to force the animals to perform a grotesque and unnatural dance called “The Big Lick.” Mitchell was said to be enamored by the Big Lick and adored the status that came with a blue ribbon, even if it meant soring a helpless horse and much worse.

According to USDA records, Jeffery Mitchell has been ticketed four times for violating the Horse Protection Act while “Mark Mitchell,” of the same address, has violated the federal law seven times. Oddly, Jeffery and Mark were each ticketed on three horses in 2010 and 2011 – Blueberry Dollar, Mo Dollar, and Black Lining. Repeat violators often enter horses under different names, different owners, or different trainers and are rarely caught. The Mitchells’ violations included soring and shoe pads.

Mitchell was named as the breeder of a world champion Tennessee Walker, a horse named Gen’s Burning Rage. It is strongly alleged Gen was in a “rage” after being repeatedly “burned” by soring techniques. It is well-known that Mitchell was apparently so consumed by world champion Walkers he would do anything for another champion. Almost every mare confiscated last Saturday was believed to be pregnant, some in late stages. It hasn’t been determined how much damage was done to the unborn colts.

• Much more. Continue reading »



Horse Soring Fact Sheet »
Horse Soring FAQ’s »

3 thoughts on “Big Licker served 55 felony counts for filthy, emaciated Tennessee Walking Horses”

  1. I signed the petition but these people need long prison sentences but none of them will ever get whats coming to them. In the article no one seemed to know why the horses were left to starve to death, if this creature could make a $ 55,000 bond then why weren’t the horses at least fed something?? You can’t even get your head around the cruelty that went on for so long. It looks like all of the followers of the these big lick horse shows protect each others backs including the local judges that some of them have been brought up before on cruelty charges. Its always a slap on the wrist not a slap to a prison cell.


  2. Well here we are again ….Horse torture and cruelty front and center involving the Tennessee Walking Horse…..It never seems to end, usually the big money men pass it off to the stable hands and now we can all see that a pharmacist is now being charged….As I’ve always said so many professionals are at the front of all the torture and cruelty that happen to these horses….Doctors, lawyers, prominent people with an education like now a pharmacist ….No surprise to me…..Money hungry jerks that care for one thing and that’s to make money at the expense of helpless creatures…..Please lets all do what we can …..First let’s all speak out against these stupid shows go to Change.Org speak out against the Gulf Coast Charity Show and all the ridiculous shows that torture these beautiful animals….The “Big Lick” is NOT natural there is NO possible way these animals do this….I have 2 Tennessee Walking Horses and even though they are some of the best riding horses with great bloodlines it is just NOT possible to achieve that walk!!!!…..Horrific acts from Horrific people needs to STOP……Once again we are hearing about these loving beautiful helpless creatures that have the most wonderful , kind dispositions and there are being tortured !!!!!!!!!!!!….Let’s boycott , write letters, stand tall for the animals that have ” NO VOICE and NO CHOICE”


  3. When will people ever learn? And why in the >I*** was he allowed to make bond after having a long history of this??? Why was he even allowed to own horses again after all the other charges before????


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s